Barney Half Life 1
During a play trough of Half life 2, I noticed Barney mentions something about a cat he 'still has nightmares about'. Alyx then starts to ask a few times, without answer, what cat he refers to. It is mentioned as Barney and Kleiner debate how safe the teleportation device has become from the last time it was used.
I never got to play Half life 1, so I am curious if this is either a reference to a HL1 scene, or if it's just a random gag left for us to ponder about. I don't mind spoilers, as you get key hints trough HL2 as to what happened during HL1 anyway.
So, if it actually is a thing and not just some random gag, what cat does Barney refer to during his talk with Kleiner?
Half-Life 2 (stylized as HλLF-LIFE 2) is a first-person shooter video game developed and published by Valve Corporation.It is the sequel to 1998's Half-Life and was released in November 2004 following a five-year $40 million development. During development, a substantial part of the project was leaked and distributed on the Internet. The game was developed alongside Valve's Steam software.
Frank♦7 Answers
The cat did not appear in any of these games:
- Half Life (Source)
- Blue Shift
- Opposing Force
- Decay
- Either of the Portals
- Half Life 2 or anything released thereafter.
I'm going to call this a noodle incident (TV Tropes link, you have been warned).
SentryYou all have missed the answer completely. It is simply a reference to a scene in the movie 'the fly'. The lab is even designed to be similar to the movie.
It's a joke about Freeman getting ready to teleport in the teleporter kliener built...its not a mention of a real event in HL you have to assume the cat did not fair well from the teleporter testing...think of the teleporter scene from galaxy quest when the pig creature was beamed aboard inside out then exploded.
This cutout copy from the half life wiki page about Kleiner might reveal something:
Barney worked as a double agent for the local Civil Protection forces at this time, while in the meantime ensuring that Kleiner's Lab would go undiscovered and safe from the Combine. At one point, Kleiner finished his teleport, and tested it with a cat, apparently resulting in its death, forcing Kleiner to resume work on it.
The first part says that Barney provided protection for Kleiner's lab, so he would know about it. Skip a bit about his headcrab and this is what it says:
When Alyx grew older, Kleiner also worked with her and Barney to rescue Citizens from the Combine, and evacuate them through the Underground Railroad located in the City 17 Canals to Black Mesa East. At the time of Half-Life 2, Kleiner is finishing up his teleport.
So it was before the events of Half-Life 2 but after the events of Half-Life. This explains why no one can figure out when it happened. It also was while Alyx was a kid, so it was not too long after Half-Life, because she says that her dad used to work with you in Black Mesa.
So, it happened a while after Half-Life. Wow, that was a long answer.
angussidneyThe 'cat' is a reference to Kleiners pet Headcrab, which Barney has a phobia of. It could also be as discussed above, as an actual cat in an accident with the teleporter.
pinckerman
The cat they are talking about is Schrodinger's cat. Its an old thought experiment proving the Uncertainty Principle in Quantum Mechanics. The experiment goes: 'if you place a cat in a box with a poison to released based on particle decay, you can not state what the cat is - he is neither dead nor alive until the box is open'. It also shows the superposition theory where an unobserved item contains both states (the cat being neither dead or alive until observed). The achievements a pun based off this where the cat died so they observed that it is in fact dead and not both.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schr%C3%B6dinger%27s_cat
Prof. Kliener has a pet headcrab that gets up to lots of mischeif.(Makes the teleporter go haywire, in HL2EP2 in the missile silo he climbs inside the machinery inside a hatch in the rocket and just sits there.)
I think that they are referring to Kliener's Headcrab.(Weird.)
protected by Wipqozn♦Dec 20 '16 at 2:55
Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).
Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?
Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged half-life-2 or ask your own question.
For one reason or another I managed to totally miss playing any of the Half-life series. I have the time and money now to play these games that I have heard such great things about. So what are all the Half-life games that I should play? and what order should I play them in?
I am confused of where the episodes and expansions all fit in. And what they mean by 'Source' versions. Are these even part of the same series? And what about Blue Shift, Lost Coast, or Opposing Force? So many games, and I don't know where or if they fit.
Are there any in the series that I should skip, or just read the plot summary for? Can someone please give me a run-down of what I should play, in order.
Frank♦7 Answers
The must-play Half-Life games are Half-Life 1, then Half-Life 2. The expansions and spin-offs for Half-Life 1 which were not developed by Valve are quite skippable; Opposing Force, Blue Shift and Decay return to the setting and events of Half-Life 1, but portray the story through the eyes of a U.S. Marine, a security guard and two scientists (since Decay is a cooperative multiplayer game), respectively.
The Source version of Half-Life 1 is, and I quote:
a digitally remastered version of the critically acclaimed and best selling PC game
Needless to say it's smoke and mirrors, there's absolutely no significant difference between the two.
My advice is to play the original Half-Life 1, then Half-Life 2, and if you'd like to extend the pleasure, sequels Episode 1 and Episode 2 for Half-Life 2 are quite good, but not as good as the two main games.
The HL2 episodes are not an accessory part of the story, but actual sequels. They do contain plot changing events. The same is not true for the Half Life 'One' series, as far as I know.
Thus:
- Half Life
- Half Life 2
- Half Life 2 Episode 1
- Half Life 2 Episode 2
As for Portal -- it does contain some side references to corporate entities in the Half Life universe, but as it is that's more flavor than actual plot.
badpbadpThe Source versions are a remake of the original games on the engine used by HL2. Half Life: Source is pretty much identical to Half Life.
The recommended playing order is pretty much the release order:
- Half Life (Or Half Life: Source)
- Half Life: Opposing Force
- Half Life: Blue Shift
- Half Life: Decay (skippable - PS2 only)
- Half Life 2
- Half Life 2: Episode One
- Half Life 2: Episode Two
Half Life 2: Lost Coast is just a tech demo for graphics options that went into later Source games. If you want to be quick, you can skip everything but Half Life and Half Life 2.
Portal is also tangentially related to the Half Life plot, but isn't too important as it doesn't have much story of its own. Portal 2 may change this however.
MachaMachaAs already pointed out, the most logical order is to play the games by their initial release dates. This is assuming you want to follow the Half Life story from start to finish.
- Half-Life - You take control of Gordon Freeman in the Black Mesa facility
- Half-Life: Opposing Forces - You play as one of the marines during the events of the original game
- Half-Life: Blue-Shift - You play as a security guard during the events of the original game
- Half-Life 2 - Years later you take control of Gordon Freeman in a new story
- Half-Life 2 Episode 1 - Continue as Gordon Freeman after the events of Half-Life 2
- Half-Life 2 Episode 2 - Continue as Gordon Freeman after the events of Half-Life 2 Episode 1
Someone has already mentioned 'Half-Life Decay'. This is a coop game mode available on the Half-Life PS2 release. It takes place during the events of the first game. It is possible to play this on the PC (as someone has managed to port it onto the PC).
Lost Coast is a very short demo. It takes part in the realms of Half Life 2, but from memory the location doesn't appear in the full game.
Half-Life also has a rich mod community. One of the stand out mods would be the Black Mesa project - whereby Half Life 1 is being remade into the Source engine, used to make Half Life 2. The difference between this mod and the Half-Life: Source release is that the graphics are being completely polished.
Depending on your tolerance, or appreciation, for older games, it is feasible to completely skip Half Life 1, or at least the expansions. They were great games but are still old games. Not to say Half Life 2 isn't an old game.
Will you miss anything not playing Half-Life 1? Not really. The story in Half-Life 2 is so different. A different time, a different location, different enemies... If Half-Life 1 never existed, Half-Life 2 would still be a great game and story.
If you play Half-Life 2 then the episodes are worth going through as they immediately follow events from the main game. There is also a cliff-hanger at the end of Episode 2. Episode 3 never appeared and people have been waiting a generation for the next installment.
Portal has been mentioned but the game is not like Half-Life. Don't assume that you MUST play Portal 1 and/or 2 because you played Half-Life.
There appears to be a lot of opinion and speculation generated from this question, so I am going to use the Wikipedia listing of the chronological Half-Life games, in order to give a rough overview of each game in the series. See below on my thoughts for deciding if you should play certain titles.
Which Games Should I Play?
I can't really tell you. The Half-Life series is so broad and diverse that it spans many releases, some official, some not. I have provided meta-reviews, where applicable, to help provide a general consensus of quality; However, due to different opinion, you might very well enjoy titles that were effectively shunned by the general community.
For this reason, I would mostly advise you to do your own research. Watch somebody play on YouTube. Read your own reviews on the game. In some cases, you can purchase packs of older titles at a good price, so you might consider buying a set of games and making your decision within the first hour or so of game-play.
There are some absolutes I can provide, that is, what games you should play for the purpose of story. Please keep in mind that some games are re-makes, in one way or another. In such cases, I will only list the original version. It is again up to you, personally, to decide whether you would have a greater experience replacing said title for the newer version, or if you in fact wish to play the very first release.
I am very interested in the story, including minor plot.
The following titles provide story, and are ordered in approximate order. There are several games the occur around each other, from alternate points of view, which can easily be played in any order. Furthermore, there are several titles that do not provide any form of story, which will be omitted.
Half-Life -> Half-Life: Opposing Force -> Half-Life: Blue Shift -> Half-Life 2 -> Half-Life 2: Episode One -> Half-Life 2: Episode Two
I am only interested in major story, and do not wish to involve minor plot.
The following title order will provide you with the main Half-Life plot. They are the main releases, with the episode releases intended to replace the expected long waiting time for Valve to develop an entirely new game.
Half-Life -> Half-Life 2 -> Half-Life 2: Episode One -> Half-Life 2: Episode Two.
The Games
Half-Life (also see Black Mesa)
- Genre: Single-Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 1998
- Developer:
- Valve Corporation (original release)
- Gearbox Software (PlayStation 2 port)
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux and PlayStation 2
- Engine:GoldSrc
- Metacritic Score:96 on PC, 87 on PlayStation 2
- GameRankings Score:94 on PC, 83 on PlayStation 2
- Notes: The first game in the Half-Life series, this game will take you back to where it all began, placing you in control of main protagonist Gordon Freeman. According to the developer, Half-Life has won over 50 Game of the Year awards, and sold over 20 million copies.
Half-Life: Source
- Genre: Single-Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2004
- Developer: Valve Corporation
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:no score
- GameRankings Score:no score
- Notes: Half-Life, remade using the Source engine. It is worth noting that this particular release was criticised for not being a complete remaster, which lead to the development of Black Mesa.
Half-Life Deathmatch: Source
- Genre: Multi-Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2006
- Developer: Valve Corporation
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:no score
- GameRankings Score:no score
- Notes: The multi-player component of the original Half-Life, remade using the Source engine. Much like Half-Life 2 Deathmatch, this game is simply a multiplayer game, and does not have any story.
Half-Life: Opposing Force
- Genre: Single-Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 1999
- Developer: Gearbox Software (under direction of Valve)
- Platform: Windows, OS X and Linux
- Engine:GoldSrc
- Metacritic Score:no score
- GameRankings Score:85 on PC
- Notes: Valve gave the development reigns to Gearbox, for this title, in order to focus on other projects. It is played from the perspective of Adrian Shephard,
A member of the marine squad sent in to 'clean up' Black Mesa in Half-Life.
Half-Life: Blue Shift
- Genre: Single-Player First Person Shooter w/ Multiplayer
- Original Release Date: 2001
- Developer: Gearbox Software (under direction of Valve)
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux and PlayStation 2
- Engine:GoldSrc
- Metacritic Score:71 on PC
- GameRankings Score:67 on PC
- Notes: Another title developed by Gearbox, in this title, players take control of Barney Calhoun.
Barney Calhoun is a security guard in Black Mesa, and a central character in Half-Life 2.
Another feature this game brought was the inclusion of high-definition models and textures, which would also upgrade Half-Life and Half-Life: Opposing Force.
Half Life: Decay
- Genre: 2 Player Co-op First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2001
- Developer: Gearbox Software (under direction of Valve)
- Platform: PlayStation 2
- Engine:GoldSrc
- Metacritic Score: no listing
- GameRankings Score: no listing
- Notes: Designed as a 2 player co-op, for release with the PlayStation 2 version of Half-Life, Decay puts the players in control of two scientists inside Black Mesa. While only officially released for PlayStation 2, there also appears to be an unofficial port to PC.
Black Mesa
- Genre: Single Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2005
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: PC
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score: no listing
- GameRankings Score: no listing
- Notes: Black Mesa is designed as a remake of Half-Life using the Source engine. This game is currently in early access. This means that if you pay for the game, now, you can play it, now. But it is not, in any way, a finished product. This is the main reason for no Metacritic or GameRankings score, although in house, Steam have received 'overwhelmingly positive' reviews from the players, at the time of writing this. You can ask questions about this game, since it is semi-available to the public. But be aware that only a select group of people will be able to answer them.
Half-Life 2 (see Lost Coast, included with HL2)
- Genre: Single-Player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2004
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux, Xbox, Xbox 360 and Shield Portable
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:96 on PC
- GameRankings Score:95 on PC
- Notes: Sequel to Half-Life, this is the first game to put players back in control of Gordon Freeman. It is critically acclaimed, and has sold over 12 million copies.
Half-Life 2: Deathmatch
- Genre: Multi-player First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2004
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: Windows, OS X and Linux
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:74 on PC
- GameRankings Score:no score
- Notes: Half-Life 2: Deathmatch is simply a stand alone multiplayer component for Half-Life 2. It allows you to compete, online, but does not involve any story.
Half-Life 2: Lost Coast
- Genre: First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2005
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: Windows, OS X and Linux
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:no score
- GameRankings Score:no score
- Notes: Lost Coast is a technology demonstration. It was created to showcase the high-dynamic-range rendering capabilities of the Source engine. While this was released separate to Half-Life 2, it should be considered 'DLC' or an additional level, and is included with the purchase of Half-Life 2.
Half-Life 2: Episode One
- Genre: First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2006
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux, Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:87 on PC
- GameRankings Score:86 on PC
- Notes: Half Life 2: Episode One is the first episodic sequel to Half-Life 2. Given the long wait between Half-Life and Half-Life 2, Valve have decided to focus on releasing episodes, in effort to reduce the long waiting period between game releases. The player takes control of Gordon Freeman, again, with a greater focus on developing the other characters.
Half-Life 2: Episode Two
- Genre: First Person Shooter
- Original Release Date: 2007
- Developer: Valve
- Platform: Windows, OS X, Linux, Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3
- Engine:Source
- Metacritic Score:90 on PC
- GameRankings Score:91 on PC
- Notes: Half Life 2: Episode Two is the second episodic sequel to Half-Life 2, and direct sequel to Episode One. It was developed alongside Episode One, to give the two titles a greater sense of immersion.
Half-Life 2: Episode Three
The internet is filled with rumors concerning Half-Life 2: Episode Three. Is it really coming? Have Valve ditched the 'episodic structure', and instead, working on Half-Life 3? You will see 'episode three' listed within the game series, but be aware that most of it, at present, is speculation. When the game is released, this answer can be edited to include the appropriate information. I would speculate that, given the amount of time since Episode 2 compared to the time it took to develop Episode One and Episode Twp, and the expectation that an entire Half Life game would take a lot more time, we should be expecting Half Life 3 rather than another episode.
Further Information
- There seems to be some users who advise 'don't play that game, it was not made by Valve'. All Half-Life games listed above were made under direction of Valve. They gave control of a majority of original Half-Life titles to Gearbox, so they could work on other titles. Gearbox is the company behind Borderlands and Duke Nukem Forever, two very conflicting examples of widely-accepted first-person shooters, so my best advice is don't knock it unless you have tried it.
- If you are unsure about playing a game, look up the reviews. You should be playing the game because you think you will enjoy it, not because a group of fanboys say its bad. Just because I like apples, does not mean you have to. Thats what makes us human.
- You can find any missed story collected together on the Half-Life Wikia. I have deliberately used the scores from MetaCritic and GameRankings, as they attempt to give an aggregated average across many other reviews. If you are the sort of person that looks at what the reviews have to say, before playing, go to a website you respect the opinion of, and see what they have to say. This is not the place for personal opinions.
- The portal series is a series in its own right, but acts as a sort of 'spin-off' to the Half-Life series. While not directly related, one could assume they are set in the same fictional universe, with references to Black Mesa lightly used in-game.
Furthermore, it is possible to 'replace' the Gravity Gun in Half-Life 2 with the Portal Gun from Portal, with some easy manipulation on the user-end.
ok.... i read all the answers above, and i must agree in some parts and disagree in others. If anyone really wants to have more than just a simple answer like my fello slacker answers above, read this. If you become a true fan and wants to know about the game (more than just playing, but to treat the storyline as a master piece like if it was a book), then this is the order and reason why to play them:
Half-Life OR Half-Life Source OR Black Mesa (Which is a remake on a Half-Life 2 source mode but at the current time I write this, is developed by Valve to be sold on Steam for a low price).
Half-Life: Oppossing Force OR Operation: Black Mesa ( which at this time is being developed but not finished, is a remake in the Half-Life 2 source mode, it merged with the delevopment team of Guard Duty).
Half-Life: Blue Shift OR Guard Duty ( not finished but development in progress, same team of Operation: Black Mesa, remake on the source mode of Half-Life 2.
Half-Life: Decay OR Decay Or Hazard Team (if u do not have a ps2, a ukranian team ported the game to pc, named Decay, Hazard Team is not finished and the development not progressing, source mode Half-Life 2 remake, lets hope they group up with the other modder remake teams so this will be finished).
Half-Life 2
Portal
Half-Life 2: Episode One
Half-Life 2: Episode Two
Portal 2
Note that Gearbox games are not yet decided to be cannon or not... if they decide they are ( which Half-Life: Blue Shift is most likely to the presence of Barney Calhoun on Half-Life 2), then you would not want to play some new storyline without a clue what they are talking about because you skipped the previous games, besides... they are all fun :P
Portal games are in the same universe and you never know when they are going to combine the characters from within.
And guys.... That is how you answer someone's question :)
AND FOR THE COMMENT OF THE GUY ABOUT BLACK MESA:
If you learn to read... i said it is developed by Valve to be SOLD, not to be finished. AND it is being worked by their development team to finish the chapters in Xen. I mentioned the mods to give a little bit of credit... even though they are not done, they still put effort on them (except Hazard Team, lets keep hoping they finish working on it. That is as far as i know aboht that mod, that is dead. if is not or you have some kind of information about it that i have not mentioned or you might want to add... please write it so i can be informed).
AND as i must add and restate: playing this expantions and Portal games are just to know and/or be prepared for any other storyline it could come ahead, if u got the time and money as you said.... go ahead and play them all.... if not then just play what you feel like it..... this was just my recomendation. It would not surprise me, in fact, i am expecting for Valve to recommend players in some kind of announcement to play Black Mesa as they call it cannon for the storyline (when they finish Xen ofcourse). If the other mods are as good as Black Mesa... my opinion goes the same for them.
(add-ons include, opposing force, blue shift, decay, and the mod remake of half life 1, Black Mesa).
Then play, Portal 1 (if you have it). Half life 2, HL2 episode 1, HL2 episode 2, Portal 2, and then maybe play TF2 just for fun.
Half-life 1 Download Torrent
That's my recommendation. =D (Also, even though Black Mesa is still incomplete, it still does a good job of re-creating HL1 and making it look even better then before, you should play it even more since now it has multiplayer, but still, just a recommendation). That said, please play it after HL1 to compare, and play HL2 after. Thanks! Just wanting to state my opinion!